Pros and Cons of Donating Eggs (From Firsthand Experiences) May 16, 2024 | by Lucy Solie-Vilker, Program Director

If you are considering becoming an egg donor, it’s important to thoughtfully weigh the pros and cons of donating eggs to decide whether it’s the right choice for you. In this blog, we give a clear breakdown of the benefits and challenges of egg donation. These lists were compiled from actual egg donor experiences to deepen your understanding of the process, requirements, and potential side effects. It’s our mission to provide potential egg donors with transparent information, and we hope this blog leaves you feeling empowered to make an informed decision. Let’s dive in!

The Pros of Donating Eggs

Below, we share some of the main benefits of egg donation. These sentiments are often expressed by donors as they are in the midst of the process or once they have completed their egg donation cycle.

1. Fulfilling Dreams of Parenthood

At the top of our list is the intrinsic reward of egg donation — the opportunity to help individuals or couples achieve their dream of starting a family. By donating eggs, you have the power to make a meaningful impact on someone else's life, offering hope and the possibility of parenthood where it may not have existed before.

As shared by Victoria Nino, a mother via donor eggs,

"When I think of our egg donor, I have so much gratitude in my heart. Thanks to her donated eggs, I get to be a mom to the most incredible human being ever created."

2. Financial Compensation 

As an egg donor, you will receive financial compensation for your time, effort, and dedication to the egg donation process. While you are in a cycle, it should be your #1 priority and some donors even describe it as if it is a job. So, financial compensation is certainly deserved, and many programs offer quite generous compensation at that. Financial compensation can be a significant benefit, helping to alleviate financial burdens such as student loans or living expenses. 

3. Personal Growth and Empowerment 

The egg donation experience can be deeply rewarding on a personal level, enriching your life in ways you may not have anticipated. Our donors often share that they feel a sense of pride and fulfillment in knowing they've played a crucial role in helping others build their families. Many of our donors conclude the process feeling stronger, more confident, and empowered from the experience.

4. Gain Invaluable Insights Into Your Own Fertility

Another surprising perk of egg donation is that the process will give you insights into your own fertility and reproductive health. The medical evaluations you will undergo, such as determining your AMH levels, can be helpful for your future family-building goals. Depending on your cycle, you may even complete a genetic screening consultation which will let you know whether you are a genetic carrier of certain conditions. 

The Cons of Donating Eggs

We believe in transparency, and part of that is acknowledging the cons of donating eggs. Although it’s super common for our donors to want to donate eggs multiple times, that doesn’t mean it’s necessarily a walk in the park. Below, we share some of the most common cons of donating eggs as shared by previous donors.

Pros and Cons of Egg Donation

1. Possible Discomfort and Side Effects 

It's important to acknowledge the physical aspects of egg donation as the process involves self-injecting fertility medications and undergoing an egg retrieval procedure. Side effects may include bloating, fatigue, and discomfort leading up to and after the egg retrieval. While these symptoms are temporary, they can be challenging to navigate during your egg donation cycle.

2. Emotional Considerations 

Egg donation is not without its emotional complexities. Donors may experience a range of emotions through the process, partially due to the hormone medications which can cause mood changes. It’s important to tell at least one loved one that you are donating eggs to have their support as you go through the process. Additionally, we can’t stress enough the importance of taking care of your body and prioritizing your self-care and emotional wellbeing as you complete your cycle.

3. Requires Commitment and Dedication

In addition to the time commitment, the egg donation process will require you to complete medical screenings, monitoring appointments, and legal and psychological consultations. Additionally, there’s a good chance you will have to travel for the egg retrieval and possibly even the last phase of your cycle (all expenses will be covered). 

4. Lifestyle Adjustments

Lastly, egg donors are required to abstain from intercourse, smoking, drug use, alcohol, and caffeine consumption during their cycle. It's important to consider how egg donation will fit into your life and whether you're prepared to make the necessary commitments.

Pros and Cons of Donating Eggs: Shared by Previous Donors

While you will have the opportunity to consult with counselors and medical professionals during the process, we’ve found that reading firsthand experiences gives the best insights into what it’s really like to be an egg donor. So, we’ll tie our lists of pros and cons together with a quote from our previous egg donor S.H., perfectly highlighting the benefits and challenges of being an egg donor:

“Fertility, and specifically egg donation, is often a private topic. There are some articles online, but nothing really captures the joys and pains of donating your eggs. I have completed my second donation in six months and am looking into a third, and final, cycle with Donor Nexus.

Egg donation is an extremely rewarding process, as ultimately you are giving the potential gift of life. Knowing that you helped someone start or add to their family is unlike any other feeling. The minor discomforts are well worth the end result. However, any female looking into egg donation should be prepared for the process. Egg donation is a job. You must be prepared to sign on for all the elements of the process. Daily injections, eating right, not exercising, and abstaining from alcohol are all things expected of a donor. Dedication is key. Honestly, the daily injections are minimally painful and, when done correctly, have no bruising or bleeding. I almost look forward to my injections because it means I am one day closer to giving my eggs to the intended parents. Not all donors will react to the medication as I do but be prepared to gain a few pounds (easily lost after the donation). Personally, I had a rough recovery time after my first donation cycle. It took about three weeks for the bloating and discomfort to subside. I was extremely nervous for my second cycle.

Never be afraid to talk to your doctor or nurse about your body and how you are reacting to the medication. I tend to tough things out, but in this instance, it can be more harmful than helpful. My second cycle was almost pain-free compared to my first, directly caused by my nurse and doctor listening to my needs and tailoring my medication schedule. If you have any unnecessary discomfort, tell your nurse right away. It makes the process so much easier on the body. I have learned more about female fertility and my body through egg donation than I could ever have been taught by textbooks. I would recommend egg donation to anyone, whether you know anything about fertility or not. Donating with Donor Nexus is the experience of a lifetime, an opportunity I am extremely grateful for.”

Empowering Egg Donors to Make Informed Decisions

At Donor Nexus, we are committed to supporting and empowering egg donors every step of the way, making sure that they feel confident and empowered throughout their journey. If you’re ready to take the first step, we invite you to view our egg donor requirements and apply online today!

Find Additional Resources in the Donor Nexus Blog:

Get in Touch

We are always here to answer any questions you may have. Contact us today to start your journey!